The Hawaii Community
Foundation
More ways to Pluck a Non-Profit
Sightings from The Catbird Seat
~ o ~
From The Hawaii Community Foundation website:
About Us
Hawai‘i Community Foundation - A Closer Look
The Hawai‘i Community Foundation is a public, statewide, charitable services and grantmaking organization supported by donor contributions for the benefit of Hawai‘i's people.
What We Do
We are an information resource for philanthropy, civic leadership and the issues affecting the nonprofit sector. As an advocate for the nonprofit sector, we seek to inspire the spirit of giving throughout every island community by providing outstanding support and services to our donors, volunteers, other nonprofit agencies, grantseekers and the community....
Officers and Other Supporters
Name/ Position:
Robert A. Alm/Vice Chairman; Claire L. Asam/Governor; Eugene Bal III/Governor; Robert R. Bean/Governor; Gary L. Gifford/ Chairman; Lawrence M. Johnson/Governor; Gerry J. Keir/Governor; Paul Kosasa/ Secretary; Violet Loo/Governor; Webb F. Martin/Treasurer; Margaret Masunaga/Governor; Bill D. Mills/Governor; Sada Okumura MD/ Governor; Jan C. Rudinoff/Governor; Jennifer Sabas/Governo;r Myles S. Shibata/Governor; Jenai Wall/Governor; Jeffrey N. Watanabe; Governor; Thomas P. Whittenmore/Governor; Ronald 'Buzz' Wo/Vice Chairman; Sylvia Yuen/ Governor
http://www.hawaiicommunityfoundation.org/
January 22, 2006
From Jack and Marie Lord,
a parting gift of $40 million
By Rick Daysog, Advertiser Staff Writer
Jack Lord, whose long-running crime drama "Hawaii Five-0" introduced Honolulu to millions of television viewers, amassed a fortune in excess of $40 million, which is all going to a dozen Hawai'i charities.
Lord, who died in 1998, and his wife, Marie Lord, who died in October, were savvy investors who accumulated a large portfolio of stocks, bonds and real- estate investments.
The endowment also includes Jack Lord's sizable collection of celebrity memorabilia, such as "Hawaii Five-0" mementos, his paintings, photos, and gifts from longtime friends Sammy Davis Jr. and Elvis Presley.
The $40 million will be used to create the Jack and Marie Lord Fund, which will generate an estimated $1.6 million to $2 million a year, to be divided among 12 Hawai'i nonprofits.
The charities, selected by the Lords, are Hospice Hawaii, St. Francis Hospice Care Center, the Salvation Army's Hawai'i division, Eye of the Pacific Guide Dogs Inc., The Association for Retarded Citizens in Hawaii, the Bishop Museum, Variety Club of Honolulu, the Hawaiian Humane Society, the United Service Organizations, the Honolulu Academy of Arts, Hawaii Public Television and the Hawaii Lions Eye Foundation.
"This basically means that we can continue operating in Hawai'i," said Sean Wofford, executive director of Hawai'i Lions Eye Foundation, a nonprofit that will receive as much as $100,000 a year from the Lords' endowment.
The organization operates a donor bank for eye tissue.
The dozen charities will receive $32,000 to $340,000 a year, said Kelvin Taketa, chief executive officer of the Hawaii Community Foundation, which will administer the fund.
The Lords' $40 million gift is one of the largest to a charitable organization.
A $100 million endowment was set up for the benefit of 16 local community organizations by Big Island rancher Maude Woods Wodehouse, who died in 2003.
Don Horner, chief executive officer of First Hawaiian Bank, which has handled the Lords' investment, banking and estate- planning needs for more than 40 years, said that most of the Lords' assets were in the form of stocks, bonds and real- estate partnerships.
The Lords' condominium at the Kahala Beach apartment complex will be sold and the proceeds added to the fund.
The $40 million gift does not include Jack Lord's substantial collection of memorabilia, which has not yet been appraised. Clothing made by Marie Lord and videos of "Hawaii Five-O" episodes also are part of the collection.
The collection eventually will be auctioned off, said Horner.
"I don't think its value is in the millions of dollars, but being the prudent trust officer, we are intent on maximizing the value to carry out his wishes," Horner said....
The Lords' relationship with the Hawaii Community Foundation dates back to 1988, when they set up a fund to benefit the 12 charities with a $50,000 gift.
The fund grew to about $750,000 at the time of Jack Lord's death.
September 16, 2007
Hawaii's rules lax on
oversight of charities
By Rob Perez, Advertiser Staff Writer
Hawai'i is one of only 11 states that do not require charities to register, a gap that allows thousands of local nonprofits to raise millions of dollars from the public with virtually no regular oversight from regulators.
The lack of a registration requirement, considered the foundation of an effective monitoring system by many national experts, means charities can collect donations from residents without anyone from the state making even cursory checks to see how that money generally is spent.
"Charities aren't getting much oversight in Hawai'i," said Peter Swords, who has taught nonprofit law at Columbia University in New York for about 30 years. "With nobody looking at you, it means people can abuse the charity system. It's as simple as that."
Although the vast majority of Hawai'i's 5,000 public charities follow the rules and have financial safeguards in place, some organizations invariably stray from their tax-exempt missions — usually without drawing any scrutiny from the state.
Without a registration system that provides for annual reviews, regulators typically intervene only if someone complains or the questionable conduct is flagged some other way.
Take the case of Alphabetland Preschool & Kindergarten, a family-run, Waipahu-based charity that has an average monthly enrollment of 300 students and annual revenue of roughly $2 million, according to its tax returns.
For three consecutive years, starting in 2002, the Waipahu nonprofit paid one of its top executives more than $250,000 annually, far more than what officials earn at education institutions much larger in size. At KCAA Preschools of Hawai'i, a nonprofit that had double the enrollment and revenue as Alphabetland during that same period, its top executive earned less than $75,000 a year.
Over roughly that same period, Alphabetland also loaned more than $100,000 to another officer of the charity — the husband of the top-paid one — while he earned a salary of up to $120,000. Hawai'i law prohibits nonprofits from loaning money to their officers and directors. The husband served in both roles.
The wife's pay, which raised questions of excessive compensation, and the husband's loan were duly noted on Alphabetland's federal tax returns from 2001 to 2004.
But because Hawai'i has no registration system, which usually includes the filing of a charity's tax return, the Alphabetland transactions went unnoticed by state regulators — until one of them read a national story about questionable loans to nonprofit officials. The story had a brief Hawai'i reference, eventually leading the state attorney general's office to the Waipahu charity.
Authorities found more red flags once they started digging.
They learned, for instance, that the tax-exempt organization had paid its husband-and-wife management team, Gary and Amy Arizala, about $1 million from 2000 to 2003 (Gary Arizala died in 2004) and that the nonprofit was leasing two luxury cars, a Jaguar and Volvo, for $1,200 a month.
They also could see from the tax returns that the Arizalas were listed as Alphabetland's only board members during the period the husband was borrowing money and the wife's annual salary peaked at $264,000. The couple's daughter was added as a third board member in 2004, the returns show.
Such an arrangement runs afoul of standards that watchdog groups such as the Better Business Bureau recommend for governance of charities, including having a board that is independent, free of self-dealing and has at least five members.
Alphabetland declined comment except to say it was in discussions with the AG's office, has not admitted any liability and cautioned against jumping to conclusions about the issues raised by the state.
"We are confident that the matter should be resolved in the not-too-distant future to everyone's mutual satisfaction," the charity said in a June statement.
The AG's office declined comment because the case is still pending.
CRIMES AND MISDEEDS
The issue of charitable oversight has taken on greater significance in Hawai'i because of some relatively recent high-profile cases of misconduct or alleged misconduct. Among the cases:
A Salvation Army official on O'ahu was fired last year after he stole more than $300,000 in money and property that elderly donors had intended to give to the charity. It was later disclosed that the official had been hired by the organization even though he had a previous conviction in Colorado for bilking an elderly couple. The man pleaded guilty to theft, forgery and other charges last week in connection with the Salvation Army case.
A soccer league volunteer was sentenced to five years of probation last year for stealing more than $40,000 from her O'ahu nonprofit group.
A former politician was accused in 2005 of improperly transferring $130,000 in campaign funds to a Waipahu charity he headed. The matter was referred to the AG's office for a criminal investigation.
Those cases and other publicized ones delivered some damaging public-relations blows to Hawai'i's industry, raising questions about whether the state and charities themselves have sufficient safeguards in place to protect against abuse.
The federal government grants tax-exempt status to charities, but it does so few audits — far less than 1 percent of all nonprofits nationally — that oversight has fallen largely to the states. The Internal Revenue Service did not have statistics on audits of Hawai'i nonprofits.
The quality of charity monitoring varies considerably from state to state, with some jurisdictions devoting entire divisions to it. Pennsylvania, for instance, has about 30 people, including attorneys and support staff, in its charitable trusts and organizations section. Oregon has nearly 20.
In Hawai'i, the AG's office, which is responsible for charity oversight, doesn't have even one full-time deputy assigned exclusively to that task.
That dearth of resources was reflected in a December 2004 survey by the National Association of State Charity Officials. Of the 30 states that responded, every one had more budgeted positions — from clerks to attorneys — dedicated to charity oversight and enforcement than Hawai'i, which at the time had none. Today, it has one.
"Oversight (around the country) generally is pretty lax," said Burnis Morris, a Marshall University journalism professor who specializes in nonprofit issues. "But at least some oversight is better than none."
Proponents say registration systems provide states with valuable information on what groups are out there collecting money, what they're collecting it for, how they're spending it in a broad sense and other aspects of a charity's operations. The information can help enforcement officials spot red flags, such as questionable transactions or compensation deals, and answer questions from the public.
Having regulators review annual filings also can serve as deterrents to abuse and is designed to give donors confidence that someone independent of the organization is watching to protect their interests.
National experts say Hawai'i's lax system, one of the weakest in the nation, is worrisome.
"I can't think of another state that has less of a commitment to regulating charities and protecting the interests of donors," said Trent Stamp, president of Charity Navigator, a watchdog group based in New Jersey.
"It really sounds like a wild west atmosphere," said Daniel Borochoff, president of the American Institute of Philanthropy in Chicago.
IN-HOUSE WATCHDOGS
Industry officials, however, say Hawai'i nonprofits generally have done a good job of protecting donor interests, spending money efficiently and keeping misconduct at bay.
"I'm not aware of any wholesale abuses," said John Flanagan, chief executive of the Hawai'i Alliance of Nonprofit Organizations. "I think Hawai'i nonprofits have a pretty good track record."
The board of directors of each organization provides some outside oversight, many charities hire outside accountants to review their books, and nonprofits that receive funding from government agencies and private foundations have to file reports accounting for how those dollars are spent, according to charity executives.
"The nonprofit sector here is subject to much greater scrutiny than any (government) agency," said Nanci Kreidman, executive director of the Domestic Violence Clearinghouse.
Adding to that dynamic, the tight-knit nature of the industry in an island community means word quickly spreads when a charity strays from its mission, so nonprofits go to great lengths to protect their integrity and the trust of donors, the executives say.
"Reputation is what they live by," said Kelvin Taketa, president of the Hawai'i Community Foundation.
Taketa and other executives agree that the AG's office doesn't get nearly enough funding to provide oversight under the existing system, let alone under any expanded one. They particularly laud Hugh Jones, the deputy AG who provides the bulk of that oversight, including maintaining the office's Web site on charity fundraisers. Jones, however, also has other, non-charity-related duties. The main responsibility of the tax division he heads is to provide representation to the state Department of Taxation.
"Hugh does a terrific job," Taketa said of Jones' nonprofit duties. "But frankly we need four Hughs, not just one."
Guarding against abuse is critical to the industry because charities rely on public support, and donors will be reluctant to give if they don't trust that their money will be used wisely.
The stakes are considerable.
Hawai'i residents give hundreds of millions of dollars annually to philanthropic causes. In 2001, the most recent year for which statistics were available, local residents donated about $430 million in goods and money to Hawai'i and national charities, according to a 2002 study commissioned by the Hawai'i Community Foundation.
The funds that go to local nonprofits help support a sizeable chunk of the state economy. Hawai'i's 5,000 charities control more than $12 billion in assets. Another 500 private foundations, formed by companies or wealthy families to help fund charitable services, control $1.2 billion in assets.
All told, these nonprofit organizations generate more than $2 billion in revenue, employ more than 41,000 people and pay wages topping $1 billion.
Given such weighty numbers, even if a tiny fraction of charities stray from their missions and divert assets for non-charitable purposes, the impact can be significant, according to regulators.
NO REGISTRATION SYSTEM
That was among the arguments the AG's office made several years ago when it attempted to get a registration system resurrected in Hawai'i. Registrations were required here until legislators repealed the law in the mid-'90s. But lawmakers were unwilling to support a new statute that the AG's office proposed in 2001 and 2002.
While Hawai'i has a strong law regulating paid solicitors for charities and another statute allowing the state to remove directors for fraud or gross abuse, Jones said a registration system would provide valuable information that would help the public separate the good charities — the vast majority — from the bad and enable the AG's office to better monitor the industry.
One of the big drawbacks of not having an effective system is that consumers have no single place to turn to for comprehensive, timely information about charities seeking donations. Would-be donors, for example, can't check to see if an organization that they're unfamiliar with and that is asking for donations is a legitimate charity registered with the state. They also can't see if the organization has provided the state with information on its finances.
Some watchdog groups, such as the Better Business Bureau (www.give.org) or Charity Navigator (www.charity_navigator.org), provide online evaluations of certain charities, but the offerings tend to be limited or the participation of charities is voluntary.
A charity's federal tax returns, called 990s, also are available online (www.guidestar.org), but regulators and others often lament that the returns can be untimely, inaccurate or incomplete. Nonprofits with income of $25,000 or less and most faith-based groups are not required to file 990s.
TAX DEDUCTIONS AT RISK
Without a registration system, local donors who contributed more than $74,000 in 2006 and early 2007 to the Music Foundation of Hawai'i likely wouldn't have known that the charity was involuntarily dissolved by the state Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs in 2004 and not re-incorporated until January 2007.
That meant the donors' contributions during that period were not tax-deductible, according to the AG's office.
Under a typical registration system, a significant change in status — such as an involuntary dissolution — would have to be reported to the state AG's office, and that information likely would have been added to what was publicly available about the charity.
The Hawai'i AG's office came across the music foundation case only because the charity's paid fundraiser, Hawai'i Promotions, was required to register with the state under the charitable solicitations law. All paid solicitors fall under that law.
Hawai'i Promotions' license was suspended in May for 90 days, partly for providing misleading information to foundation donors, according to the AG's office. The company didn't contest the suspension and paid a $3,000 fine.
In providing receipts to the donors, Hawai'i Promotions included its federal tax identification number and a "Keep this portion for your records" statement, implying that donations were tax-deductible, Jones said in a May letter to the fundraiser.
But even though the foundation had formally incorporated again, its previous tax-exempt status didn't apply to the new organization, meaning donations in 2006 and 2007 were not tax-deductible, Jones said in the letter.
Johnny Kai, the foundation's executive director, denied that the charity or the fundraiser was attempting to mislead anyone.
The foundation was involuntarily dissolved because of a technicality that Kai wasn't even aware of until the AG's office sent him a notice, according to Kai.
He also said the IRS recently told him the foundation's tax-exempt status still was good — the IRS Web site indicates as much — but the agency recommended that the charity reapply anyway because of the state's contention. Kai has done that.
"It was all innocent," he said. "We weren't trying to fool anybody."
The need to oversee charities is not just limited to the smaller, less obscure ones, analysts say.
High-profile, more mainstream organizations also can slip up, sometimes unknowingly.
That apparently was the case when the Honolulu Academy of Arts, as part of a compensation package to its newly hired president and director in 2003, loaned Stephen Little money to help him with a home purchase.
When the charity's board learned the following year about the AG's position on such lending practices, it immediately addressed the issue: the board and Little decided that he would step down as an officer of the academy but maintain his position as chief administrator.
"This was done to comply with the law and to prevent either a conflict (of) interest or the perception of a conflict of interest," Little said in an e-mail.
He repaid the loan in full in 2005.
Although the academy mentioned the loan on its tax returns the past several years, the AG's office wasn't aware of it until last week — when The Advertiser called to inquire about it.
August 19th, 2005
Commission refers Kawamoto case
for criminal investigation
By Associated Press
HONOLULU (AP) _ The state Campaign Spending Commission has referred its two-year investigation of former state Senator Cal Kawamoto to the attorney general's office for a criminal probe.
The commission cited alleged abuses, including the improper transfer of 130-thousand-dollars of his campaign funds to a Waipahu charity that he heads.
Commission executive director Bob Watada says the case involves a gross misuse of campaign funds. He says Kawamoto planned to drain all the assets of his campaign funds.
Kawamoto defended his actions before the commission and accused the commission staff of destroying his political career. He lost his re-election bid last November after 10 years in office.
http://www.kpua.net/news.php?id=6023
August 21, 2003
Kona philanthropist leaves
$122 million endowment
By Robbie Dingeman, Advertiser Staff Writer
Maude Woods Wodehouse, who lived a quiet life as a Big Island rancher, has left an endowment of more than $122 million to benefit several Hawai'i community organizations and schools.
The 87-year-old Kona resident died July 2 at her home, leaving tens of millions of dollars in trusts to support Punahou School, Seabury Hall, Bishop Museum, the Salvation Army, the Nature Conservancy of Hawai'i, Hawai'i Community Foundation and others, her family said.
Her sister, Alice Gamble, said Wodehouse (pronounced Woodhouse) preferred to remain behind the scenes when she made donations over the years to schools, historic preservations and nature groups.
"She didn't want to take a lot of credit," Gamble said.
Wodehouse, whose maiden name was Ackerman, married Cenric N. Wodehouse in 1934, a year after her graduation from Punahou School. Her husband was a grandson of Victoria Ward. "That's where the bulk of her inheritance came from," said Les Gamble, her brother-in-law and Alice's husband.
Bishop Museum President Bill Brown said her $18 million trust endowment will help ensure that the museum can "preserve the great collections of Hawai'i and the Pacific for which it is home — to study them, and to tell their stories to the people of Hawai'i and of the world."
Seabury Hall headmaster Joseph Schmidt confirmed that his school will benefit from an $18 million income-generating fund. Schmidt said Wodehouse had a long connection with the school and had given anonymously before. "It is certainly an incredibly generous philanthropic thing to do," he said.
Nature Conservancy director Suzanne Case said Wodehouse left her organization a trust worth $9 million. Case said she was surprised by the generous bequest even though Wodehouse had donated before.
"She leaves a great legacy that we will all benefit from," Case said. "We're just very, very grateful for her vision and generosity."
Although Wodehouse will likely be remembered for these large donations, Les Gamble said she gave generously for many years to many people, including a $500,000 donation to Kona Hospital and two $25,000 donations to Hospice of Kona.
Doug Philpotts, retired president of Hawaiian Trust Co., had known Wodehouse for more than 20 years and had worked with her. "Maudie was really a gracious lady," Philpotts said. "She had kind of a wonderful sense of humor. She was a delight to work for."
Although she and her husband had no children, they contributed much to education over the years, he said. "Both she and Cen were interested in supporting private education, specifically providing for teachers' salaries at many places."
Les Gamble said Maude and her sister used to play bridge every Thursday. And she lived quietly in a fabulous setting, a 12,000-square-foot French farmhouse designed by renowned architect Vladimir Ossipoff on a 1,500-acre ranch that her husband bought in 1947.
Alice called her sister fun, charming and stubborn. In a sign of the humor she shared with her husband, the two named their ranch Poho Kala, Hawaiian for "no money."
And as generous as she was with others, she spent little on herself, Les Gamble said. "She never spent anything on herself. We used to kid her about it."
Bank of Hawaii's Katherine Anderson is sending out letters to the organizations named by Wodehouse. She said the amounts left in trusts vary and a complete list of the exact amounts of the bequest wasn't yet publicly available.
"This isn't the first of her philanthropic efforts by any means," Anderson said. "She's been incredibly generous for many years, oftentimes, anonymously."
Salvation Army spokesman Daniel De Costa declined to provide details but confirmed "a significant contribution in the form of a trust and the annual earnings are to be used for the operations of the Salvation Army here in Hawai'i."
February 19, 2004
Hawai'i Community Foundation gives out
$380,077 in grants statewide
Advertiser Staff
The Hawai'i Community Foundation has awarded $380,077 in grants from its Mo' Bettah Together program to 33 community projects statewide. The projects are:
• O'ahu: Adult Friends for Youth, Pu'uwai Momi Parent Involvement Project; American Civil Liberties Union of Hawai'i Foundation, Hawai'i Juvenile Justice Project; American Friends Services Committee, youth leadership retreat and talk-story sessions; Boys & Girls Club of Hawai'i, empower residents to take back McCully-Waikiki-Mo'ili'ili; Chaminade University of Honolulu, Project SHINE; Good Beginnings Alliance, Kuhio Park Terrace keiki play area improvements; Greater East Honolulu Community Alliance, Kaimuki Parking Solutions; Hawai'i Intergenerational Network, increase senior resources in elementary schools; Ho'ala School, service learning project; Moanalua Middle School, student-community partnerships' Olomana Foursquare Church, Kailua ICE Task Force; Parent Participation Nursery School, involvement with high school parenting course; Planned Parenthood of Hawai'i; faith-feminist cooperation; Punahou School, public and private school student environmental steward project; YMCA of Honolulu, 'Ewa Beach community policing.
• Big Island: Church of God, Lanakila Residents Council; Community Development Pacific Inc., Miloli'i village wisdom program for youth; Five Mountains Hawai'i, North Hawai'i Youth Coalition; Hawai'i's Volcano Circus Ltd., performance arts; Ocean View Community Development Corp., sand volleyball court project at Kahuku Park; People Advocacy for Trails Hawai'i, Kealakehe Walks; YMCA, leadership development in community development; Waimea Outdoor Circle, community cleanup.
• Kaua'i: Garden Island Resource Conservation & Development Inc., community drug plan; Good Beginnings Alliance, Hanapepe Heights and Cliffside Parks pride; West Kaua'i Business & Professional Association, Waimea Town beautification; YWCA of Kaua'i, Lyd-gate Park art project.
• Maui: Kipahulu 'Ohana Inc., Kapahu Living farm workdays; Maui Family YMCA, Kalakupua Community Playground.
• Moloka'i: Bishop Museum, educational programs at Mo'omomi Bay; Mediation Center of Moloka'i, domestic violence task force.
• Statewide: Hawai'i Special Olympics.
# # #
MORE TO COME
For more ways to pluck a non-profit
\/
American Savings Bank: Behind the Blinds
The Mating of AOL & Time-Warner
APCOA: Buzzards in the Parking Lot
A Connecticut Yankee in King Kamehameha’s Court
Buzzards in the Bank of Hawaii
Confessions of a Whistleblower
DIRTY MONEY, DIRTY POLITICS & BISHOP ESTATE
Part I - Part II - Part III - Part IV - Part V - Part VI
First Hawaiian Bank: Behind the Blinds
The Grand (and dirty) Ko Olina
Kajima: Blood, Bribes & Brutality
The Kamehameha Schools Retirement Plan
Marsh & McLennan: The Marsh Birds
Marsh & McLennan’s Mercer Consulting
Marsh & McLennan’s Putnam Investments
Pointing the Finger at WorldPoint
The Morgan, Lewis & Bockius Report
The Rise and Fall of Summit Communications
The Vampires on Jupiter Island
The Vultures in the Halls of Justice
The Vultures in Maunawili Valley
Vultures in the Merger Markets
Vultures of the Sandwich Isles
Office of the U.S. Trustee vs Harmon
~ o ~
MORE OF THE CATBIRD’S FAVORITE LINKS
~ o ~
FAIR USE NOTICE. This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Last update January 2, 2008, by The Catbird Seat.